Study: Abortions Don’t Harm Women’s Mental Health
In fact, it's being denied an abortion that is associated with poor outcomes in the short-term
Anti-choice activists and politicians have long argued that abortion causes negative mental health issues — often as a means of justifying interfering with women’s reproductive healthcare. It’s something we just saw in Texas, where officials released a mandatorily distributed pamphlet linking abortion to depression. Several states require mandatory abortion counseling that warns women of negative emotional responses to the procedure.
But a new study published in JAMA Psychiatry suggests that women who have abortions are not at greater risk of experiencing depression or anxiety. In fact, researchers found that — wait for it, wait for it — it is denying women abortions that is associated with poor mental health outcomes.
“What we find is that denying women abortion has negative consequences to their mental health and well-being, and we find no evidence of emerging mental health problems after an abortion,” said lead author Antonia Biggs, a researcher at the University of California, San Francisco research group Advancing New Standards in Reproductive Health.
Many studies have already reported finding no evidence of negative abortion-related mental health effects. When the American Psychological Association reviewed the relevant research, it concluded that there was “no credible evidence that a single elective abortion of an unwanted pregnancy in and of itself causes mental health problems for adult women.” But the current study improves upon the methodology of that past research, according to Biggs, and provides the best evidence yet that abortion doesn’t cause mental harm.
The researchers recruited and interviewed 956 women from 30 different abortion clinics in 21 U.S. states. They were first interviewed a week after seeking out an abortion, and then semi-annually for five years. The researchers primarily focused on comparing two different groups: women who had an abortion just short of the clinic’s gestational age limit and women who were denied an abortion because they were just past the clinic’s gestational age limit.
These two groups made for a good comparison because they were similarly far along in their pregnancies and both consisted of women who wanted an abortion. It would be unfair to use a woman who is intentionally pregnant as a comparison, because of course there might be negative mental health effects simply from being unwittingly pregnant. This design made it possible to distinguish between the potential effects of not wanting to be pregnant and of having an abortion.
Within the group that was denied an abortion, things were further broken down: those who eventually gave birth and those who did not (either because they miscarried or obtained an abortion elsewhere).
The researchers found that one week after first seeking an abortion, it was the women who were beyond the gestational age limit and therefore denied the procedure who suffered. Compared to women who sought out an abortion while near the gestational limit, these women who were denied an abortion reported more anxiety, lower self-esteem, and lesser life satisfaction. The only measure that was similar in both groups was depression.
As the study puts it, “compared with having an abortion,
But the researchers found that “psychological well-being improved over time so that both groups of women eventually converged.” In other words, five years later, these groups were doing just about the same in terms of their mental health. “That is something that is surprising to me, that women who are denied an abortion were so resilient and the negative effects weren’t longer term,” said Biggs.
The ultimate takeaway here is that abortion isn’t associated with depression, anxiety, low self-esteem, or a poor sense of well-being. As the researchers conclude, “These findings do not support policies that restrict women’s access to abortion on the basis that abortion harms women’s mental health.” Of course, politicians find plenty of other ways to limit abortion — including Ohio Gov. John Kasich who just signed a 20-week abortion ban on the grounds of “protecting the sanctity of human life.”