Canadian singer Justin Bieber performs on stage during a concert as part of his "Believe" World Tour at the Sevens Stadium in Dubai May 4, 2013. Bieber will perform another concert in Dubai on Sunday. REUTERS/Jumana El Heloueh (UNITED ARAB EMIRATES - Tags: SOCIETY ENTERTAINMENT) - RTXZALL

Psy, Bieber and My Journey Into the World of Fake YouTube Views

It was all prompted by a strange email I received the other day

A couple of weeks ago, I received a phone call to my office line from an unavailable number. I picked up. “Get a paper and pen,” the voice instructed me. I asked who it was. “Write down ‘Rantic,’” the male voice said slowly and deliberately. I asked once more who he was. “Expect an email from me in 10 minutes,” he replied. He hung up.

About an hour later, an email came through containing two screen shots. The first was what appeared to be Scooter Braun—the well-known talent manager behind Justin Bieber and Psy—having a Skype conversation with a person named “Kenzo.” Braun (if it was really him) appeared to be buying around 200 million YouTube views for an unnamed video. “We do not want any traces or any low-quality views that can get us in trouble,” the screen shot showed Braun as saying.

A second screen shot attached appeared to show Braun sending a PayPal payment for $150,000, though the recipient’s address was blocked out and there was little else in the way of identification. The anonymous sender wrote: “Image originates from a worker who works at Rantic in the YouTube views/Facebook Likes department. They took down their site & their services as soon as a hacker from 4chan went into their database and stole their images/data.”

On top of this, the emailer sent links to several to stories about politicians who fake Twitter followers, and musicians who inflate their popularity by buying fake views. “Good luck,” he concluded. “Hope to see your story all over international news outlets.”

The message obviously piqued my curiosity. First of all, you have someone claiming that the manager of some of the world’s biggest celebrities is buying their online popularity, not earning it legitimately. These aren’t just “promoted” views, either. These are views that are just straight-up fake.

Then you have the mention of Rantic, a shadowy group that at the time meant nothing to me. But while reporting out this story, the group became linked to the Emma Watson nude photo hack, which was later determined to be a hoax. And a few days after that, Rantic itself got hacked.

I wanted to untangle the threads that my tipster had dangled in front of me. That has led me down a weird and confusing path, putting me in touch with people that operate on a first-name-only basis.

YouTube views aren’t some quaint little marketing component or minor audience-building tool. They can make or break a new career—and add a lot of money to the bank accounts of existing stars. They’ve become so relevant to the industry that Billboard now factors in YouTube view counts when creating its Top 100 rankings.

Problem is, lots of YouTube views “earned” by top celebs have been shown to be fake views. In December 2012, at the height of the “Gangam Style” craze, The Daily Dot reported that Google removed some 2 billion YouTube views on videos owned by Universal Music Group, Sony/BMG and RCA Records. Regardless, Psy’s “Gangam Style” video stands as the most watched YouTube video of all time, with 2.1 billion views (though the veracity of those views have been called into question before).

The Google crackdown hasn’t completely wiped out the phonies, though. One of the people I spoke with along the way, “Robert,” the anonymous founder of YouTube view vendor comparison site, told me, “Companies are not only trying to top one another, but also trying to stay one step ahead of YouTube.”

He continued, “The bots watch other videos (not just the client’s video), they like, dislike and comment. They even use proxies/TOR to create a unique identity for each individual bot that’s very hard to detect.”

To understand the cat-and-mouse game, I also talked with “Martin V,” the owner of the YouTube view site “You can make upwards of $1,000 day by selling views,” he said. “[The market is] very hot [because] the potential to make so much is money is so high. …It’s a very dog-eat-dog competition out there.”

So that’s why and how Justin Bieber’s manager might have bought view counts. (Braun’s camp hasn’t responded to my request for comment). But did he?

Respond Now

My Breast Twerking Video Got 30 Million Views, and I'm Appalled

Sarah Natochenny

Yo! Science! Jaden Smith’s 1-Word Tweets, In All Their Confusing Glory

Molly Fitzpatrick

The Rich Kids of China's Rulers Are Livin' Large in California

Kristie Hang

Mother Russia Kills Santa

Sarah Kaufman

New South Korean Internet Fad: Watching Other People Eat Online

Tierney Bonini

Nazis + Hipsters = "Nipsters": Hate Gets a Makeover

Joel Stonington

Juggalos Claim Anti-Hipster Campaign Is an FBI Frame Job

Shane Dixon Kavanaugh

Are Cops in Your City Wearing Body Cameras?

Abigail Tracy
Join the Fray
“Rollin’ Coal” Is Pollution Porn for Dudes With Pickup Trucks