Feb 16, 2008 - Oxnard, California, USA - Mourners remember 15-year-old E.O. Green Junior High School eighth-grader on Saturday Feb. 16, 2007 in Oxnard, Calif. Larry King was an eighth-grader that was perceived by classmates as a gay or crass-dressing student who had been bullied. Friends said he became more dramatic with makeup and dressed more flamboyantly in the last two weeks prior to him being fatally shot by a classmate. No details have been released from authorities on a motive. The shooting has brought upon critical observation to how middle schools address and prevent discrimination that could lead to violence. (Credit Image: © Afton Almaraz/ZUMA Press)

California to Ban “Gay Panic” Defense in Criminal Trials

Using junk science, defense attorneys have justified violent assaults on the LGBT community since the 1960s. Now one state aims to outlaw their dubious arguments

Larry King was typing an English paper in the computer lab of his Oxnard, California, middle school in 2008 when another student, 14-year-old Brandon McInerney, shot him execution-style in the back of the head. The day before King’s murder, the openly gay 15-year-old had told McInerney “Love you, baby!” and asked him to be his valentine.

When the court tried McInerney on hate crime charges, his lawyers invoked what’s called the “gay panic” defense. The legal strategy aims to justify the assailant’s actions by arguing that they were a hysterical reaction to the victim’s homosexual advances. McInerney’s defense team claimed he felt threatened and harassed by King’s flamboyant behavior—King wore high-heeled boots and mascara and openly flirted with his bullies, including McInerney—and he eventually snapped.

The argument worked. The trial ended in a hung jury, and McInerney, who faced life in prison, eventually pled guilty to a lesser charge and was sentenced to 21 years.

Brandon McInerney, left, shot and killed the openly gay Larry King, right, in 2008. 

This wasn’t the first time that a gay panic defense was used in a criminal trial. Lawyers have relied on that tactic in hundreds of cases dating back to the 1960s. Now the California legislature is pushing through a bill that would ban such defenses from state criminal courts. According to the bill’s sponsor, Assemblywoman Susan Bonilla, the legislation sends a message that violence against the LBGT community is not acceptable. “This is 2014!” she said during the initial proposal. Should it pass, the bill would become the first of its kind in the country.

“This defense has actually victimized dead individuals,” says D’Arcy Kemnitz, the executive director of the National LGBT Bar Association, which has been leading the effort to ban the legal strategy. “It has victimized people who can no longer stand up for themselves because they are dead and gone as a result of society’s bias against their sexual identity.”

The notion of gay panic is rooted in the field of psychology, which once characterized homosexuality as a mental illness. Psychologist Edward Kempf coined the term “homosexual panic” in 1920 to describe people who were terrified that they might be gay. This compulsively anxious state was even recognized by the American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders starting in 1952, but the diagnosis became obsolete in the early 1970s, when homosexuality was removed from the manual as a mental defect.

Gwen Araujo, a transgender teen, was killed after four men discovered she was biologically male. 

Even so, the faux condition has continued to surface in cases where LGBT individuals were assaulted or murdered. The defense lawyers’ arguments generally center on insanity (alleging that the victim’s sexual advances triggered a nervous breakdown or psychotic episode in the perpetrator), provocation (the victim was basically asking for it by making unwanted sexual advances) or self-defense (claiming that the victim’s actions, although nonviolent, were sufficiently threatening because of his or her sexual orientation).

In recent years there have also been cases involving “trans panic” defenses, such as the 2002 murder of Gwen Araujo, a 17-year-old transgender woman. Araujo was beaten and strangled to death by four men—two of whom she had previously had sex with—after they discovered she was biologically male. One of the attackers’ attorneys argued that he acted not out of malice, but rather that he was provoked by the shock of learning that Araujo was transgender. Jurors in the initial trial were divided, but the man was found guilty of second-degree murder in a second trial.

Kemnitz says the California bill marks a major step forward in eliminating bias in the criminal court system. “One question we will never know the answer to is this,” she says, referring to the King trial of six years ago. “Would the jury have deadlocked if the victim had been a teenage girl who said, ‘Be my valentine’?”

SEND US A FACT!

Thank you for
submitting your fact.

Be sure to follow and subscribe

Queer Index Factbot #QUEERINDEX
  • Embed this item

    In Columbus, Ohio, only 20% of Facebook users who self-identify as gay men also list themselves as single.

    Analysis of Facebook profiles' meta data

  • Embed this item

    On average, the ratio of self-identified gay men to lesbians on Facebook is 1.3 to 1 in the top 100 most populous cities in the U.S. 

    Analysis of Facebook profiles' meta data

  • Embed this item

    Boston reports the highest number of sexual-orientation hate crimes (63) per year of the top 100 U.S. cities.

    Open data analysis: SPLC stats

  • Embed this item

    NYC is the best city for random pickups: On average, there are 440 rent boys and 2,200 posts looking for hookups on Craigslist per day.

    Analysis of Craigslist & Rentboy posts

  • Embed this item

    Washington, D.C., has the most anti-LGBT groups (3), while NYC has the most hate groups in general (18).

    Open data analysis: SPLC stats

  • Embed this item

    In Memphis, Tennessee, more than 52% of Facebook users who self-identify as gay men also list themselves as single.

    Analysis of Facebook profiles' meta data

  • Embed this item

    Looking for a nice girl? Memphis, Tennessee, has the highest percentage of lesbians who are single (40%).

    Analysis of Facebook profiles' meta data

  • Embed this item

    For the top 100 cities in the U.S. by population, on average there are 10 w4w posts on Craigslist each day, compared with 183 m4m posts.

    Analysis of Craigslist w4w forums

  • Embed this item

    NYC has the largest gay population (64,000), according to Facebook. Los Angeles ranks second (42,000) and Chicago is third (20,000).

    Analysis of Facebook profiles' meta data

  • Embed this item

    In San Antonio, more than 52% of Facebook users who self-identify as gay men also list themselves as single.

    Analysis of Facebook profiles' meta data

  • Embed this item

    Gay nightlife is as good as it gets in NYC. The Big Apple has 403 gay clubs in addition to the 2,150 gay bars.

    Analysis of Yelp listings

  • Embed this item

    Of the 50 states, California has the highest number of same-sex couples; Nebraska has the lowest.

    Open data analysis: US Census' stats

  • Embed this item

    Atlanta has the highest number of GayborhoodApp-certified businesses (685)--almost 3.5 times more than Chicago, the next city.

    Analysis of GayborhoodApp listings

  • Embed this item

    Los Angeles has the most bathhouses (8), closely followed by San Francisco, Portland, Oregon, and Columbus, Ohio, which all have 6.

    Analysis of Gaycities listings

  • Embed this item

    Los Angeles has 2,424 gay bars but only 168 lesbian-specific watering holes (not counting ladies' nights at gay bars).

    Analysis of Yelp and Gaycities listings

  • Embed this item

    Lakeland, Florida; Oxnard, California; and Provo, Utah, have the fewest LGBT bars or clubs (6, 5 and 5, respectively).

    Analysis of Yelp and Gaycities listings

  • Embed this item

    The sportiest city is NYC, with 30 different LGBT-only leagues. Los Angeles ranks second with 19, Chicago and D.C. third with 17 apiece.

    Analysis of Rainbow Flags and Outsports

  • Embed this item

    Chicago has the highest print circulation of LGBTQ papers (in total, almost 1.55 million).

    Gaydata circulation and readership stats

  • Embed this item

    Los Angeles (No. 1 overall) and San Francisco (No. 3) both have 171 lesbian clubs each. NYC (No. 2) trails with 135.

    Analysis of Yelp listings

  • Embed this item

    According to Facebook data, the ratio of self-identified gay men to lesbians in San Francisco is 1 to 0.66.

    Analysis of Facebook profiles' meta data

  • Embed this item

    Salt Lake City has the lowest percentage of lesbians who are single (25.5%) of the top 100 most populous cities in the U.S.

    Analysis of Facebook profiles' meta data

  • Embed this item

    Nashville, Tennessee, has three LGBT-only sports leagues.

    Analysis of Rainbow Flags and Outsports

  • Embed this item

    According to Facebook, NYC has the largest lesbian population (74,000). Los Angeles is second (44,000) and Chicago third (22,000).

    Analysis of Facebook profiles' meta data

  • Embed this item

    San Jose, California, has almost 25 w4w posts a day, according to Craigslist. That's the same as Portland, Oregon.

    Analysis of Craigslist w4w forums

  • Embed this item

    According to Facebook data, the ratio of self-identified gay men to lesbians in Memphis, Tennessee, is 1 to 2.3.

    Analysis of Facebook profiles' meta data

  • Embed this item

    According to Facebook data, the ratio of self-identified gay men to lesbians in Baltimore is 1 to 2.

    Analysis of Facebook profiles' meta data

  • Embed this item

    According to Craigslist, NYC has the most w4w posts, with an average of 55 per day. Atlanta and Los Angeles spar for second with 46 each.

    Analysis of Craigslist w4w forums

  • Embed this item

    Los Angeles averages the most gay bars (2,424), according to Yelp and Gaycities. NYC and San Francisco are runners-up with 2,150 each.

    Analysis of Yelp and Gaycities listings

Respond Now
ISRAEL

VIDEO: Gaza Militants Tunnel Into Israel and Attack an Outpost

Markham Nolan
SOCIETY

Data Proves That Everything You Know About Millennials Is WRONG

Elizabeth Kulze
SOCIETY

If You're Going to Unfollow Anyone, You Should Probably #UnfollowAMan

Brian Feldman
SOCIETY

Men Just Won't Stop With the Public Sexual Harassment of Women

Mariah Wilson
SOCIETY

This Amateur Einstein Has the Ladies All Figured Out

Elizabeth Kulze
CRIME

The Brooklyn Bridge White Flags Whodunit Gets Personal

M.L. Nestel
DRUGS

Meet "The Budtender" - Denver's Top Weed Sommelier

Bryan Schatz
PHOTOS

Inside Gaza's Smuggling Tunnels

Vocativ Staff
Join the Fray
“Rollin’ Coal” Is Pollution Porn for Dudes With Pickup Trucks