CELEBRITY

How Many Male Instagram Celebrities Are Selfie Psychopaths?

CELEBRITY
Jan 13, 2015 at 3:25 PM ET

The time-honored tradition of guessing which of our favorite celebrities are dangerous psychopaths—as opposed to just clinical narcissists—may now be slightly more precise, thanks to a recent study published in the journal Personality and Individual Differences. The research suggests that men who flood their social media profiles with selfies tend to exhibit greater antisocial impulses.

For the study, 800 men between the ages of 18 and 40 answered survey questions that asked, among other things, how often they posted photos they took of themselves on social media. The participants also answered a standard questionnaire that screened for antisocial behaviors, including narcissism and psychopathy.

Those who took more selfies tended to exhibit greater psychopathic and narcissistic traits, according to researchers. To be clear, there is no precise threshold that determines when exactly a painfully vain man becomes the next Patrick Bateman (the study looked at the number of selfies posted over one week). Nor does chronically posting selfies online mean the person in question is psychotic.

“You can kind of see selfies as maybe a little bit of a red flag that they may have higher than normal tendencies toward narcissism and psychopathy,” says Jesse Fox, a professor of communication at The Ohio State University and lead author of the study.

With all this in mind, Vocativ wanted to see how some of the most fawned-over men on social media stacked up against one another when it comes to selfie-taking and psychopathic tendencies. First, we identified the 50 most popular men on Instagram using Iconosquare, which tracks user profiles on the site. Then we looked at each subject’s last 50 posts to determine how many of them were selfies. (We defined selfies strictly as photos of the subject taken by the subject, but had we expanded that count to include images posted of oneself in general, Justin Bieber would trigger all kinds of red flags, with 38 of his last 50 photos featuring himself prominently as the subject.)

Though more anecdotal than scientific, our findings help inform some valuable takeaways. It’s probably best to steer clear of Snoop Dogg, boy bands and Brazilian soccer stars. James Franco, for all the attention his selfies attract, falls into the middle of the pack. And Eminem and Justin Timberlake share something new in common: They don’t publish many pictures that they take of themselves.

Most Likely Psychopaths (10+ selfies in last 50 posts)

Neymar, Brazilian Soccer Player

Selfies: 23

Austin Mahone, Teen-Pop Sensation

Selfies: 17

Thiago Silva, Brazilian Soccer Player

Selfies: 15

Snoop Dogg, Rapper

Selfies: 15

Dani Alves, Brazilian Soccer Player

Selfies: 14

David Luiz, Brazilian Soccer Player

Selfies: 14

Ian Somerhalder, Actor

Selfies: 13

Cesc Fàbregas, Spanish Soccer Player

Selfies: 11

Michael Clifford, Vocalist, 5 Seconds of Summer

Selfies: 11

Borderline Psychopaths (5 to 9 selfies in last 50 posts)

Usher, Singer-Songwriter

Selfies: 9

Sean “Diddy” Combs, Rapper, Entrepreneur

Selfies: 9

Mariano Di Vaio, Model

Selfies: 9

Matthew Espinosa, Internet Star

Selfies: 8

Niall Horan, One Direction Member

Selfies: 8

Trey Songz, Singer-Songwriter

Selfies: 7

Justin Bieber, World-Famous Canadian

Selfies: 6

James Rodriguez, Colombian Soccer Player

Selfies: 6

Bruno Mars, Singer-Songwriter

Selfies: 5

James Franco, Actor, Director, Poet, Thinker

Selfies: 5

50 Cent, Rapper

Selfies: 5

Kevin Durant, Power Forward

Selfies: 5

Floyd Mayweather, Boxer

Selfies: 5

Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson, Muscle-Bound Entertainer

Selfies: 5

Lionel Andrés Messi, Argentinian Soccer Player

Selfies: 5

In the Clear (0 selfies in last 50 posts)

Eminem

Ludacris

Meek Mill

Barack Obama

Pharrell Williams

Gareth Bale

Justin Timberlake